DPDP's Consent Manager Regime Goes Live While the Watchdog's Boardroom Stays Empty — A Compliance Paradox India Cannot Afford
The State Is Building the Plane While Flying It There is something deeply unsettling about a data protection regime that activates its consent architecture before it appoints the people meant to police it. Yet that is precisely where India finds itse...
The State Is Building the Plane While Flying It
There is something deeply unsettling about a data protection regime that activates its consent architecture before it appoints the people meant to police it. Yet that is precisely where India finds itself in November 2026. The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 — a statute that has been more discussed than operational since its enactment — has now crossed a significant threshold: the consent manager registration framework is live, the portal at dpbi.gov.in is accepting applications, and Indian companies with a minimum net worth of ₹2 crore can formally register as consent managers. But the Data Protection Board of India (DPBI) — the very body that will oversee, inquire into, and penalise violations — still has no appointed members.
This is not a minor administrative lag. It is a structural contradiction that should concern every lawyer advising clients on data governance in India today.
What the Consent Manager Framework Actually Does
Under the DPDP Rules, 2025, consent managers are envisaged as registered intermediaries — platforms that will enable data principals to give, manage, review, and withdraw consent in a streamlined, interoperable manner. Think of them as the plumbing layer of India's consent architecture, analogous in some ways to the Account Aggregator framework in the financial sector, but with far broader application across every sector that processes personal data.
The framework became operational on 13 November 2026 — exactly twelve months after the DPDP Rules were notified, as the one-year gap provision dictated. MeitY's official release confirms the ₹2 crore net-worth threshold and directs eligible Indian companies to apply through the DPBI portal. On paper, this is a milestone. In practice, it raises an immediate question: who at the DPBI is reviewing these applications?
LiveLaw's reporting has been blunt on this point. The Board's vacancy is not a technicality — it goes to the heart of whether the DPDP framework can function as a credible regulatory regime. If consent managers are registered by an administrative apparatus without Board-level oversight, the legitimacy of those registrations could itself become a litigation point down the line.
The Removal of Difficulties Order: Necessary but Insufficient
Separately, the Removal of Difficulties Order, 2026, notified on 5 October 2026 and effective the following day, addressed two specific drafting ambiguities. First, it clarified that Section 9(1) requires verifiable consent before processing personal data of a child or a person with disability who has a lawful guardian. Second, it substituted "audit" with "data audit" in Section 10(2)(c)(ii), aligning it with Section 10(2)(b), which already mandates Significant Data Fiduciaries (SDFs) to appoint independent data auditors.
The "data audit" clarification is genuinely useful for practitioners. It resolves what was becoming a tedious interpretive debate: are SDFs required to conduct general corporate audits or specific data-protection audits? The Order settles this — it is the latter. For law firms structuring compliance mandates and for companies drafting RFPs for audit services, this removes a layer of unnecessary ambiguity.
But let us be honest about what this Order does not do. It does not address the far more consequential ambiguities that continue to plague the Act — the breadth of government exemptions under Section 17, the absence of a clear journalistic exemption, the undefined contours of "legitimate uses" under Section 7, and the procedural vacuum around the right to nominate. These are not drafting errors; they are structural choices that the government appears content to leave vague, and vagueness in a privacy statute almost always favours the data fiduciary — particularly when that fiduciary is the State itself.
The Constitutional Challenges: Press Freedom and RTI in the Crosshairs
The Supreme Court is now seized of multiple challenges to the DPDP framework, and two lines of attack deserve close attention from practitioners.
The Digital News Publishers Association (DNPA) — representing the digital arms of approximately 21 major news organisations including The Indian Express, The Hindu, India Today, NDTV, Network18, and the Times Group — has challenged both the Act and the Rules on grounds that go to the core of press freedom. The argument, in essence, is that the DPDP's broad definition of "personal data," combined with its complaint-and-penalty mechanism and the absence of a robust journalistic exemption, creates a chilling effect on investigative journalism. A bench led by CJI Surya Kant with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana issued notice on 27 October 2026 but declined interim stay.
The second challenge targets Section 44(3) of the DPDP Act, which amends Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, 2005 to expand the personal information exemption. Petitioners — journalists and transparency activists — argue that this amendment over-broadly shields personal information and could effectively gut RTI-based accountability, particularly where public officials' data is concerned. The Supreme Court has issued notice on a specific plea seeking interim relief against the masking or deletion of already-available data based on the amended provision.
"The DPDP Act, as it stands, gives the State the power to switch itself off from accountability with a single notification — and gives the press no clear carve-out to keep the lights on."
These challenges are not peripheral. They go to whether the DPDP Act will function as a genuine privacy statute or as a tool that simultaneously expands state data power and contracts civic transparency. The outcome of the DNPA petition, in particular, will determine whether India joins the ranks of jurisdictions that treat journalistic data processing as a protected activity — or whether it leaves every investigative reporter one complaint away from a DPBI proceeding.
What This Means for Practice
For lawyers advising corporate clients, the immediate imperative is clear: the compliance build-out cannot wait for May 2027. The Cabinet Secretary's letter of 20 August 2026 has already put Union Ministries, State Governments, and Union Territories on a time-bound compliance clock — directing them to map personal data processing, designate senior officers for DPDP compliance, review privacy notices, and audit third-party arrangements. If the government is holding itself to this timeline (at least on paper), private entities have no excuse for complacency.
Specifically, practitioners should be advising clients on:
Data mapping and classification: Understanding what personal data is held, where it flows, and whether the entity is likely to be classified as an SDF — with the attendant obligations of independent data audits and Data Protection Officer appointments.
Consent architecture: Evaluating whether to build proprietary consent management systems or integrate with registered consent managers once they become operational. The ₹2 crore net-worth requirement means the consent manager market will likely be dominated by well-capitalised players — possibly existing fintech and health-tech intermediaries.
Breach notification readiness: The DPDP's breach notification obligations (to both the DPBI and affected data principals) are significantly more demanding than what most Indian companies are currently prepared for. Incident response plans need to be drafted, tested, and board-approved well before May 2027.
RTI advisory: For lawyers representing media organisations, civil society, or public interest litigators, the Section 44(3) amendment requires immediate strategic attention. Any RTI application that could be affected by the expanded personal information exemption should be filed and pursued now, before the amended provision is used to justify refusals.
The Bigger Picture
India is attempting something genuinely ambitious: building a comprehensive data protection regime from scratch, without a pre-existing institutional framework, in the world's most populous democracy, while simultaneously navigating the tensions between privacy, press freedom, state surveillance, and transparency. That it is doing so imperfectly should surprise no one. But the specific choice to activate consent infrastructure while leaving the enforcement body vacant is not an imperfection — it is a signal about priorities.
The DPDP Act, in its current form, is more comfortable regulating private data fiduciaries than constraining state data power. The consent manager framework, for all its technical sophistication, does nothing to address this asymmetry. Until the Supreme Court rules on the pending challenges — and until the DPBI is actually constituted with members who are independent in fact and not just in title — the DPDP regime will remain what it currently is: a law with impressive architecture and no one home.
Tags
Published by AnrakLegal AI