<h2>The Hook — Why This Judgment Matters Right Now</h2>
The Hook — Why This Judgment Matters Right Now When Parliament inserts a provision with the express purpose of nullifying judicial decisions, courts face a constitutional moment that goes far beyond the immediate dispute. The Andhra Pradesh High Cour...
The Hook — Why This Judgment Matters Right Now
When Parliament inserts a provision with the express purpose of nullifying judicial decisions, courts face a constitutional moment that goes far beyond the immediate dispute. The Andhra Pradesh High Court's October 2026 judgment in Bala Sreenivas Rao Somisetty v. Income Tax Officer (WP No.28520 of 2023) is precisely such a moment—and the Division Bench of Justices Ninala Jayasurya and T.C.D. Sekhar has delivered a stinging rebuke to what they correctly identify as legislative overreach masquerading as "clarification."
This is not merely a tax case. It is a fundamental statement on the limits of parliamentary power to retrospectively validate executive action, the sanctity of faceless assessment schemes, and the judiciary's role as the final arbiter of constitutional boundaries. With over 200 writ petitions consolidated, ₹21.71 lakh crores in reassessment income at stake, and the Supreme Court already having remanded the matter after disposing of SLPs, this judgment places the High Court directly in confrontation with the Centre's legislative strategy. The Court's refusal to blink deserves careful attention.
The Facts — Stripped to Essentials
The dispute traces back to the implementation of faceless assessment under the Income Tax Act, 1961. Section 151A, inserted by the Taxation and Other Laws (Relaxation and Amendment of Certain Provisions) Act, 2020, empowered the Central Government to notify schemes for faceless assessment, reassessment, and issuance of notices under Section 148. Pursuant thereto, the e-Assessment of Income Escaping Assessment Scheme, 2022 was notified on 29.03.2022, mandating that proceedings under Sections 147 and 148 be conducted through "automated allocation" and "in a faceless manner."
Notwithstanding this, Jurisdictional Assessing Officers (JAOs) continued issuing notices under Sections 148A and 148. The petitioners challenged this as ultra vires Section 151A and the 2022 Scheme. On 28.10.2025, a coordinate bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court allowed the writ petitions, holding that JAOs lacked jurisdiction once the faceless scheme was operational.
The Revenue's SLPs were disposed of by the Supreme Court on 10.04.2026 with a remand, noting that Finance Act, 2026 had introduced Section 147A—deemed effective from 01.04.2021—purporting to "clarify" that for Sections 148 and 148A, "Assessing Officer" shall mean an officer other than the National Faceless Assessment Centre or any assessment unit under Section 144B. The Supreme Court invited fresh challenge to this provision before the High Courts.
The petitioners amended their writ petitions accordingly, leading to this decisive judgment.
The Arguments — What Each Side Contended
Petitioners' Submissions:
The assessees mounted a multi-pronged constitutional attack. First, they argued that Section 147A was not clarificatory but a legislative nullification of judicial decisions, violating the basic structure—specifically separation of powers and rule of law. The High Courts had held JAO notices invalid; Parliament could not retrospectively erase this through amendment.
Second, they emphasized that Section 148 remained embedded in the 2022 Scheme without amendment. A "clarification" that directly contradicts the statutory scheme's plain language is no clarification at all.
Third, they raised a procedural bombshell: the Income Tax Act, 1961 stood repealed by the Income Tax Act, 2025 effective 01.04.2026. Section 147A, introduced through Finance Act, 2026 (which itself came into force on 01.04.2026), was an amendment to a dead statute. Section 536 of the IT Act, 2025 provided for savings of pending proceedings and existing schemes, but no express power to insert new provisions into the repealed Act.
Revenue's Defence:
The Revenue invoked the familiar armoury of fiscal legislation presumptions, arguing that Section 147A merely clarified legislative intent by distinguishing the pre-assessment stage (Sections 148A/148) from the assessment stage (Section 147). The JAO's role was limited to determining whether reassessment was warranted; actual assessment would still be faceless.
They relied on the "twin test for validating acts" from Shri Prithvi Cotton Mills Ltd. v. Broach Borough Municipality (1969) 2 SCC 283: (i) removal of the cause of invalidity, and (ii) retrospective operation. The amendment satisfied both.
On the repeal argument, they contended that Presidential assent on 30.03.2026 meant the amendment preceded repeal, and Section 5 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 would make it operative from assent date.
The Judgment — What the Court Held and Its Reasoning
The Division Bench delivered a comprehensive 156-page judgment systematically dismantling the Revenue's position across three independent grounds.
First Ground: The "Clarification" as Legislative Overreach
The Court held that Section 147A was not clarificatory but a direct legislative override of judicial decisions without removing the statutory basis for those decisions. This violated the fundamental principle articulated in State of Tamil Nadu v. M. Rayappaiah Gounder (1971) 3 SCC 1: Parliament may remove the basis of a judicial decision by valid retrospective legislation, but it cannot ask state instrumentalities to disobey or disregard court decisions.
The Court emphasized: the High Courts had found no "defect" in Section 151A or the 2022 Scheme—all they held was that JAOs lacked jurisdiction under existing law. Parliament's attempt to retrospectively confer jurisdiction without amending the Scheme itself was constitutionally impermissible. The non-obstante clause ("Notwithstanding anything contained in any judgment, order or decree of any Court") was particularly damning evidence of legislative intent to overreach judicial authority.
"By introducing Section 147A of the Act, the Legislature is trying to over reach the judgments rendered by various High Courts in this regard, in direct conflict with Doctrine of separation of powers, which is the basic structure of the Constitution." (Para 92)
Second Ground: The Scheme Remains Unamended
The Court conducted detailed textual analysis showing Section 148's inclusion in the 2022 Scheme. The proviso to Section 151A(2)—prohibiting notifications after 31.03.2022—meant Parliament had consciously frozen the Scheme's content. Section 147A's attempt to alter the Scheme's operation without formal amendment was legally incoherent. The Revenue's argument that "faceless manner" in the Scheme applied only to Section 147 assessment, not Section 148 notice issuance, was rejected as "blowing hot and cold."
Third Ground: Amendment to a Repealed Act
This is where the Court's reasoning becomes technically devastating. Finance Act, 2026 expressly provided in Section 2(a) that its provisions "shall come into force on the 1st day of April, 2026." Citing Common Cause v. Union of India (2003) 8 SCC 250, the Court held that where a statute expressly prescribes its commencement date, Section 5 of the General Clauses Act has no application. The Act could not have commenced on 30.03.2026 (Presidential assent date) when Parliament itself fixed 01.04.2026.
Since the IT Act, 1961 was repealed at midnight 31.03.2026, Section 147A was inserted into a non-existent statute. While Section 536(2)(c) and (u) of the IT Act, 2025 saved pending proceedings and existing schemes, it conferred no power to enact new provisions in the repealed Act. The amendment was "liable to be struck down from the date of its inception or nativity."
The Critique — What Went Wrong, What Could Be Better
Strengths of the Judgment:
The Court's separation of powers analysis is doctrinally sound and courageously stated. The distinction between Parliament's power to remove the basis of decisions (permissible) versus nullifying judgments directly (impermissible) is subtle but crucial, and the judgment navigates this with precision. The textual analysis of Section 151A and the 2022 Scheme exposes the Revenue's "two-stage" theory as post-hoc rationalization.
The repeal argument, while technical, is unanswerable given the express commencement clause in Finance Act, 2026. The Revenue's reliance on General Clauses Act Section 5 was always a stretch when Parliament had spoken explicitly.
Areas of Concern:
First, the Court's treatment of the Supreme Court's remand order is somewhat cursory. The Apex Court's direction to decide "preferably by 30.09.2026" and its instruction that "no adjournments may be granted" suggested urgency that this 156-page judgment, delivered on 12.10.2026, does not fully reflect. While justice cannot be rushed, the delay invites questions about judicial administration.
Second, the Court's rejection of the "twin test" from Prithvi Cotton Mills could have been more nuanced. The judgment states no "defect" was found in the earlier litigation, but arguably the "defect" was Parliament's failure to explicitly assign jurisdiction. The Revenue's validating legislation argument is not frivolous, and the Court's dismissal might benefit from deeper engagement with the validation jurisprudence developed in tax cases like Indian Aluminium Co. v. State of Kerala AIR 1996 SC 1431.
Third, the practical consequences are staggering. The Court notes 6,46,897 reassessment orders passed; all now potentially void. The "public interest" argument dismissed in paragraph 99 deserved more respectful treatment. The Court's position that "merely because there was no challenge...that by itself will not give any right to the Revenue" is legally correct but administratively brutal.
What Advocates Could Have Argued Differently:
For the Revenue, the repeal argument needed stronger structural counter-arguments. Section 536(2)(u)'s deeming provision for schemes could have been analogized: if schemes continue "deemed made" under new provisions, why cannot substantive amendments to repealed Acts operate similarly? The "savings" clause is broader than the Court acknowledges.
For petitioners, a more developed argument on legitimate expectation and promissory estoppel (raised but not elaborated) would have strengthened the non-retrospectivity claim. The faceless scheme represented a significant policy shift; assessees who restructured compliance systems in reliance on its permanence have strong equitable claims.
The Takeaway — What Practitioners Should Learn
Immediate Implications:
1. All JAO-issued notices under Sections 148A/148 from 29.03.2022 are vulnerable in Andhra Pradesh and potentially other jurisdictions. The Punjab and Haryana High Court's similar judgment (stayed by Supreme Court on 18.09.2026) suggests this is not an isolated view.
2. The repeal point is a template for challenging other late Finance Act amendments. Practitioners should scrutinize commencement clauses and repeal schedules rigorously.
3. Faceless scheme compliance is jurisdictional, not merely procedural. The Court's holding that "the same cannot be given a go by to suit the convenience of the Revenue" (para 85) establishes strict adherence as mandatory.
Strategic Considerations:
The Revenue will certainly approach the Supreme Court. Given the monetary stakes and the direct conflict with Gujarat High Court's Snehdham Trust view (which this Court explicitly rejects), a three-judge bench reference is likely. Practitioners should:
- File stay applications immediately in pending proceedings
- Preserve evidence of compliance costs incurred under faceless systems
- Consider whether res judicata applies to assessments initiated under now-void notices
Broader Trend:
This judgment exemplifies High Courts' increasing willingness to scrutinize parliamentary "clarifications" sceptically. After Vodafone retrospective amendment controversies and the Finance Act, 2016 equalization levy debates, courts are developing thicker norms against legislative interference with adjudicated rights. The "basic structure" invocation here—though the Court ultimately rests on narrower grounds—signals constitutional jurisprudence's expansion into fiscal administration.
For tax practitioners, the lesson is clear: procedure is substance. The days when jurisdictional objections could be waved away as technicalities are ending. The Andhra Pradesh High Court has ensured that faceless assessment, for all its bureaucratic complexity, remains exactly what Parliament promised—faceless, not merely selectively faceless.
Related Cases
Tags
Published by AnrakLegal AI