Supreme Court Puts NCLT on Notice: The Delay in Approving Resolution Plans Is Now a Constitutional Problem
The Apex Court Loses Patience with the Tribunal System The Supreme Court has done something it rarely does in the insolvency space — it has turned the spotlight inward, on the very institution tasked with making the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code wor...
The Apex Court Loses Patience with the Tribunal System
The Supreme Court has done something it rarely does in the insolvency space — it has turned the spotlight inward, on the very institution tasked with making the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code work. By initiating a suo motu case over delays by the National Company Law Tribunal in approving resolution plans, the Court has effectively declared that the IBC's timeline problem is no longer just an administrative inconvenience. It is a systemic failure that demands judicial intervention at the highest level.
This is significant. For years, practitioners have watched resolution plans — painstakingly negotiated between resolution applicants and Committees of Creditors — languish before NCLT benches for months, sometimes over a year, awaiting that final stamp of approval under Section 31 of the IBC. The commercial wisdom of the CoC, which the Supreme Court itself sanctified in K. Sashidhar v. Indian Overseas Bank (2019), counts for little if the tribunal simply does not hear or decide the application in time.
Why Section 31 Delays Are Destroying Value
The IBC was designed around a simple premise: time is the enemy of value. A corporate debtor in CIRP is a wasting asset. Every month of delay means deteriorating plant and machinery, fleeing employees, expiring contracts, and evaporating goodwill. The 330-day outer limit prescribed by the Code — already a compromise from the original 180-day framework — becomes meaningless if the approval stage alone consumes six to twelve months after the CoC has voted.
Consider what this means in practice. A resolution applicant who has committed hundreds of crores based on a valuation done in, say, January 2025, finds itself before the NCLT in early 2026 with a plan that may no longer reflect the corporate debtor's actual financial position. The applicant faces an invidious choice: proceed with a plan based on stale numbers, or seek modifications that trigger fresh CoC deliberations and further delay. Neither outcome serves the IBC's objectives.
The Supreme Court's suo motu intervention signals that the judiciary now recognises what insolvency professionals have been saying for years: the bottleneck is no longer at the admission stage — it is at the approval stage.
The Paradox: Record Approvals, Persistent Delays
What makes this suo motu action particularly telling is that it comes at a time when the NCLT has reportedly recorded its highest-ever quarterly performance in approved resolution plans, despite persistent vacancies across benches. This is not a contradiction — it is the heart of the problem. The tribunal is clearing more plans than ever, yet the backlog continues to grow because the volume of incoming CIRP matters far outpaces disposal capacity.
The vacancy crisis at NCLT is well documented. Multiple benches operate with reduced strength, and the appointment process for judicial and technical members has been chronically slow. The Madras High Court's decision in R. Gandhi v. Union of India (2010) established the constitutional framework for tribunals, but the practical reality is that the NCLT remains understaffed and overburdened nearly a decade after the IBC came into force.
What the Suo Motu Case Could Mean for Practice
If the Supreme Court issues binding directions — as it likely will — the implications for insolvency practice are substantial:
First, expect mandatory timelines for plan approval. The Court may prescribe a fixed period — perhaps 30 to 60 days — within which the NCLT must decide a Section 31 application after it is filed. This would mirror the approach taken in Essar Steel India Ltd. v. Satish Kumar Gupta (2020), where the Court read down the word "mandatorily" in the context of the 330-day limit but simultaneously emphasised that delays must be exceptional, not routine.
Second, the Court may direct the creation of additional NCLT benches or mandate filling of existing vacancies within a specified timeframe. This would directly address the capacity problem. Given the Court's increasing willingness to issue continuing mandamus in matters of institutional governance, this is a realistic outcome.
Third, there may be a push for greater digitisation and case management. The NCLT's recent shift to double-sided A4 paper filings — a welcome but modest reform — suggests the tribunal is aware of its administrative inefficiencies. The Supreme Court could mandate e-filing, virtual hearings for procedural matters, and automated case tracking to reduce pendency.
The Broader IBC Landscape: A System Under Stress
The suo motu case does not exist in isolation. It is part of a broader pattern of judicial anxiety about the IBC's functioning. The Supreme Court's recent holding that CIRP can continue even if the insolvency plea that triggered it was fraudulent reflects a pragmatic approach — the Court is unwilling to let procedural infirmities derail the resolution process once it has gained momentum. Similarly, the ruling that the Section 14 moratorium protects only the corporate debtor, not promoters or directors, reinforces the principle that the IBC is not a shield for those who ran the company into the ground.
The Court's decision upholding the exclusion of a debenture holder and trustee from the CoC on the ground that a role in policy-making can suffice for "related party" status is another marker of the judiciary's willingness to interpret IBC provisions purposively rather than mechanically. The definition of "related party" under Section 5(24) is expansive, and the Court's approach ensures that entities with potential conflicts of interest cannot game the CoC process.
Meanwhile, the NCLAT's decision to set aside insolvency proceedings against Polycab over ₹2.78 crore dues serves as a reminder that the appellate tribunal will intervene where the CIRP appears disproportionate to the debt in question — a welcome check on the misuse of the IBC as a recovery tool.
The Road Ahead
The Supreme Court's suo motu intervention is overdue but welcome. The IBC's credibility depends on its ability to deliver time-bound resolution, and that promise rings hollow when the final stage — judicial approval — becomes the biggest source of delay. For insolvency practitioners, the message is clear: the days of filing a Section 31 application and waiting indefinitely for a hearing may be numbered.
The real test will be in the implementation. Directions from the Supreme Court are only as effective as the institutional machinery that executes them. If the government does not move swiftly to fill NCLT vacancies and provide adequate infrastructure, even the strongest judicial mandate will fall short. But for now, the fact that the Court has taken cognisance of the problem is itself a step forward — and one that every insolvency professional in this country should welcome.
Tags
Published by AnrakLegal AI